Understanding Membership Survey Analysis
"Unfortunately, clubs rarely initiate a long-term survey
process with the purpose of
evaluating change. The
results of membership surveys are best
viewed as a means to an end, rather than an
end in themselves. Used to the club's
fullest advantage, information gathered from
membership surveys should serve as a
mechanism for interpreting change. Over
time, the true value of the membership
survey process can be seen as member
opinions shift favorably in response to
management actions." - Jerry McCoy, MCM -
from his two part article on,
Utilizing the Membership survey Process as a Vehicle
for Change, Club Management
Magazine Vol. 79 Nos.
5 & 6
In recent years
Clubwise
has taken the lead in the ability to develop a customized
membership survey, personal
to each club, addressing both current
operating issues and long-range planning
goals.
The survey results are delivered in a concise and
effective manner that allows Boards
and
Management to identify issues and deal with
them effectively. The Consultant's Analysis
is based on 20 years of marketing experience
and the evaluation of dozens of clubs. For
more information go to
References
-Three Point Survey Philosophy For Club Leaders-
1. Ask their opinions
2. Tell them what they said
3. Tell them what you are going to do about it
The Planning Process uses THE DIRECTOR'S GUIDE
FOR CLUB GOVERNANCE and THE
GOVERNANCE CHECKLIST - Publications of Premier Club Services and
THE STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT HAND BOOK.
Strategic Planning is the process by which the club leaders envision the future
of the Club and develop the necessary procedures to achieve that future. Once
the Club sets the future direction, it must establish clear goals, with targets
for completion within a specified time frame. These targets must be realistic
and obtainable.
If a strategic plan is effective, it must fulfill the mission of the Club.
Mission development is a process of facilitation of ideas to establish consensus
for the overall purpose of the organization. Before the process of mission
development is undertaken, all parties must understand the primary focus of the
industry of which they are a part.
The
Clubwise
approach to strategic planning includes a discussion of the undeniable truths of
the industry. The Club is a service business. All future efforts should be
directed at enhancing service delivery systems that will maximize value and
member satisfaction. Once the primary strategic planning template has been
established, secondary missions, goals, objectives and strategies that provide
the individual personality of the Club can be developed.
The key to a successful strategic plan lies in the ability of the facilitator to
understand the nature of the industry. Your consultant must be able to complete
a comprehensive operational audit and then have the capacity to analyze the
needs of the organization within your individual marketplace.
Clubwise
offers the highest level of operating expertise available in the private club
industry. This experience will help insure that the planning process remains
focused on enhancing member satisfaction at all levels.
Another key to any successful strategic plan is to place the Club on track to
maximize the potential within the financial constraints of the organization. To
that end, a major part of the strategic planning process deals with value and
cost / benefit relationships.
Since the club is a business, it is supported by a series of membership
purchasing decisions. From an individual's first decision to pay their
initiation fee, their ongoing decision to pay monthly dues through their daily
decisions to buy products and services, members are making financial
commitments. The Club needs to continually reinforce the fact that each decision
the member makes is a good decision. Effective strategic planning deals with
enhancing member satisfaction through the establishment of policies that result
in good value to the membership.
One of the unique elements of a
Clubwise
strategic plan is the Board Strategy Survey included in the middle of the
process. The strategy survey helps crystallize thinking and allows the
leadership to focus on developing a plan that is measurable and achievable.
“Leadership Strategy Survey"
Periodically clubs want to
approach strategic planning with a less time consuming approach. The club may
need to update an existing plan or focus on targeted issues. The BOD 'Strategy
Survey' is an alternative to the comprehensive strategic planning process.
Clubs that have established the
critical issues, but are having difficulty making real progress, may need to
refocus. The BOD strategy process is a method of doing just that. It will not
only help clubs make progress, it will also introduce leaders to new ways of
thinking about old problems.
It is easy to test products to
ensure they will do what they are advertised to do. It is more difficult to test
ideas. The
Clubwise
process will provide leaders to a way of ideas analysis that can determine if an
idea can survive as a cost viable enhancement that will promote member
satisfaction. This system of analysis is based on The Service Gauntlet,
the new handbook for managers, officers and directors of private clubs. The book
provides new insight into strategic planning and club operational thinking.
A BOD Strategy Survey includes:
-
Preliminary research at the
club. Meet with key leaders and selected staff regarding issues facing the
club.
-
Review club policies and methods
of operation with GM in areas of finance, membership, capital replacement
service levels.
-
Develop survey for the BOD to be
complete via email or fax.
-
Set half-day strategy meeting,
evaluate survey results and prepare handouts. (The meeting can take place in
the morning, afternoon or evening)
-
Present a power point
presentation of the results and facilitate a discussion of the issues.
-
Prepare a summary report of the
results to the club
The survey process can be
completed for minimal cost and includes two visits to the club, the facilitated
half-day session and a final report. The BOD Strategy Survey has the potential
of quickly identifying what the Board believes and helping set in place a
process to make sound decisions. The overall goal is that the club can make real
progress toward positive change in the organization.
“Capital Funding Template”
Clubwise
is also a leader in developing and evaluating strategic plans and capital
funding programs. A comprehensive spreadsheet template providing effective
analysis has been created by
Clubwise.
By adopting its use, clubs can insure proper planning of revenue and expenses
streams. This style of planning will provide credibility to both strategic needs
and construction finance plans.
"Operational Audits –
Food & Beverage Consulting"
Facilitated by
Clubwise
“Operational Audits”
Clubwise
will evaluate operations from the four-part perspective. We look at 1.
Facilities, 2. Membership, 3. Products & Services and 4. Governance Practices,
as each of these parts plays and important role in the success of the
organization.
When a change is made in any of
these four elements a ripple effect normally occurs on the other three. If
operating audits, directed at policies, procedures or financial consequences,
are to provide viable options for quality solutions, they must examine the
strengths and weaknesses of the club from the four-part perspective.
A Review & Evaluation
of Club Operations
St Ives Country Club
Duluth, Georgia
“Food & Beverage Consulting”
During The Survey or strategic planning process several clients have realized
shortcomings within their food and beverage services.
Clubwise
has been hired to complete a full F & B analysis addressing operational,
facility and marketing issues that can position the club to meet member
expectations and maximize satisfaction.

Westwood Club
Food & Beverage Analysis
& Recommendations
Prepared by
Clubwise
Facilitated by
Clubwise
Jerry McCoy has been involved in training over 1500 Managers at the Club
Managers Association Business Management Institute held at Georgia State
University. McCoy specialty includes effective internal marketing through social
programming and newsletters. Using Mr. McCoy's expertise
Clubwise specializes in
a variety of internal marketing tools that include developing the club
newsletter as a major communication vehicle for positive change.
Clubwise
can offer the latest ideas for improvement to membership programs, revenue
enhancement and improvement to the club’s key marketing vehicle – the club
newsletter
By
Clubwise
Since the scope of
need for services varies substantially from club to club, pricing of these
services are estimated between the lower and upper ranges.
Clubwise will visit
your club for the cost of travel related expenses only to give a complementary
assessment of needs.
FACILITY ANALYSIS
The purpose is to
evaluate the existing facilities for operating issues, building conditions and
systems problems. Services as part of the analysis include:
-
Interviews with
the club leadership, senior management and department heads to evaluate
present operating issues and roadblocks to successful service delivery.
-
Survey of member
focus groups regarding existing and future services.
-
Completing an
analysis of existing facilities, including depreciation status, image appeal,
level and quality of the competition.
-
Review and
status of building including construction, roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing
and other systems where appropriate, using local service companies.
-
Development of
future program elements for new services and facility needs. This includes
square footage evaluations and demands within each area
based on usage and growth.
The results of the
finding will be presented in report form so that master planning considerations
can be analyzed and marketing of new facilities can take place in an effective
manner. A facility analysis does not include an architectural solution that will
satisfy the program elements identified in the report.

MASTER PLANNING SERVICES
A full master
planning effort that includes an operating and facility evaluation, development
of program elements, focus group work, finance plan development, architectural
and interiors solutions and a marketing program directed towards a presentation
meeting to the membership.
Clubwise
will lead the club through the process with independent architectural
professionals. We can also assist the club in procuring permanent professional
services from companies that will stay on to complete the project once it has
been moved through the necessary political process associated with the club.
GENERAL PROJECT RELATED
CONSULTING SERVICES
Clubwise
offers multiple services to assist clubs as they deal with major capital
enhancement. Our company will serve as a Club Operational Specialist (COS) to
your club's planning needs. We can be retained for any or all parts of project
development and management.
Clubwise is hired as the representative for the club in dealing
with architects, interior design firms, club planners or other companies to
insure a smooth and effective planning process.
Clubwise
believes that services can be procured at more competitive fee structures than
the industry has grown to accept. We will negotiate contracts to insure the best
fee structures for professional services, normally saving thousands of dollars
on the outset.
General consulting
is handled on a retainer basis depending on the scope of work.
Winter
Park
Racquet Club

2007
Facility Enhancement Program
Sample Brochure Pages
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT & CONTRACT
DOCUMENT REVIEW
If construction
and renovation projects are to be successful, they must be able to deliver on
member expectations. Not only should they be aesthetically pleasing, but they
also must have operating integrity and be able to maximize the club's ability to
deliver products and services.

Clubwise
specializes in bringing operating integrity to club design. Once plans and
specifications are complete, a thorough review of the documents is necessary to
insure a successful project. Document review can uncover errors that need to be
changed prior to beginning construction. Adjustment at this time will normally
save thousands of dollars in change orders during construction.
KITCHEN & BEVERAGE SERVICE DESIGN
Design and layout
of kitchen and bar equipment is critical for the successful delivery of products
and service once the construction or renovation has taken place.
Clubwise has
extensive expertise in design & layout of kitchen and bar equipment to maximize
the functionality of the facilities in the future.
Clubwise
will work with architectural, interiors and equipment suppliers to insure
facilities can meet the operating expectations of management and allow club
staff to perform at maximum levels.


OPENING SERVICES
Clubs will invest
hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars on clubhouse facilities. Normally
these projects stretch the resources of the club and normally exceed initial
budgets.
Clubwise understands that the success of a project is its ability to
deliver on future services to the members. This requires that new facilities
have all the operating equipment necessary to deliver on these expectations.
Clubwise specializes in working with management to insure proper budgeting takes
place for opening expenses.
Clubwise
will review all operating equipment needs and work with management to insure
ordering and purchasing takes place within the necessary lead times. Our company
will assist in establishing equipment needs procurement and layout of, not only
operating equipment, but also other systems such as telephone, security, and
sound.
Clubwise
can procure the right companies to handle all your technology-related concerns.
Clubwise
can offer creative solutions that will add special distinction to new service
delivery programs. Providing guidance to new employee orientation and staff
training prior to grand opening is included in the opening services.
"Project Samples"
The Savanna Golf Club



Augusta Country Club Summer House

